Author Archives: Steve

Is Drug Addiction Really a Disease?

The test of a new “treatment” for drug addicts reported in the New England Journal of Medicine seems to assume the answer is yes, but Dalrymple notes the study has a glaring flaw:

As far as I can tell, the control group received no sham injection, so that the members of both the experimental and control groups knew exactly to which group they had been assigned, as did the experimenters assessing the results. In a ‘condition’ (if that is what heroin addiction is) in which psychology plays so large a part, this is no very slight criticism or caveat. It vitiates the whole experiment.

Read the rest here

Dalrymple hits the airwaves in Australia

Ahead of his speaking tour of Australia, which begins tomorrow with an event in Brisbane, Dalrymple has been appearing on various television programs (telly programmes?) in the country, earning far more mass media coverage than he’s probably ever received in his native Britain, where he often feels as popular as a rattle snake in a lucky dip.

First was an appearance on the ABC program The Drum, where he gamely answered questions about contemporary Australian political issues.

Next was an interview by Tony Jones on ABC’s Lateline program where a cheery Dalrymple described his general view of the modern British bogan. Readers who have rarely seen him speak in public might be surprised by his demeanor here, but to many of us Tony Daniels is one merry bloke.

Readers “Rie” and “David R” brought our attention to this appearance on ABC’s Q&A program, where Dalrymple participates in a panel discussion that also includes feminist Germaine Greer. David R notes that Dalrymple and Greer even (crikey!) agree somewhat, although when Dalrymple attributes most modern domestic violence to extreme jealousy caused by the breakdown of traditional mores, Greer just about goes off like a frog in a sock.

And lastly, Rebecca Bynum, publisher of the New English Review and an all-around sheila, kindly posted this piece on Dalrymple by Adam Creighton from The Australian (hat tip to a dose of Theodore Dalrymple for posting the original, subscription required).

After Brisbane, the speaking tour continues with events on April 18 and 21 at the Sydney Opera House and in Melbourne, respectively. Not exactly out in woopwoop!

Of Grave Concern

Dalrymple writes at Taki’s Magazine on one of his favorite places to visit, Père-Lachaise cemetery in Paris, where one encounters the graves of all manner of interesting people:

There are Iranian communists, Palestinian terrorists, Armenian writers in exile, Spanish aristocrats, and—of special resonance for me—the consul general and chargé d’affaires of Liberia in Haiti, both countries for which I have a weakness, a man with the wonderful name of Dupré Barbancourt.

Read it here

An exquisite personal history

This piece is a short review in The New Criterion of The White Road: Journey into an Obsession by Edmund de Waal, which Dalrymple describes as “a literary macédoine, as it were, of the history of porcelain, autobiography, travelogue, and philosophy”. Dalrymple credits the book for opening the reader’s eyes to a fascinating artistic medium about which most people, himself included, are ignorant. Still, he says, he would have retained more of the medium’s history had the book “been set out in a less fragmented and personal way than it is here, where it is recounted like a pilgrimage to the sources of de Waal’s art”.

Read it here (subscription required)

My Road to Damascus

In this piece at New English Review, Dalrymple thinks back to the places he visited during his extensive travels as a young man. Some of them seemed to hold out the hope of a fairy-tale life:

…a pleasant reverie of a life without politics and ideology, a cultured utopia in fact, where there is an abundance of beauty and taste rather than of things, where people treat each other with ceremonial courtesy rather than in business-like fashion at best, and even the smallest and most ordinary of things are infused with a concern for aesthetics. A more fully-human life, in fact.

All those places have “since descended into chaos and massacre”. But of course, he knew even at the time that such a life does not really exist.

Cruel and Unusual

If euthanasia is so efficacious nowadays (one Swiss company seems successful at providing swift and painless death), why then are there so many examples of botched executions? Is it just normal government incomptenence or something more sinister? Says Dalrymple:

I am inclined to the former interpretation. But in my more paranoid moments, I sometimes wonder whether the incompetence of state agents is more than just incompetence and tips over into sabotage.

Read the whole piece at the Library of Law and Liberty

Delinquents Graduating to Jihad

Dalrymple writes at City Journal on the El Bakraoui brothers, the Belgian terrorists who lived lives of crime long before they committed their atrocities. Their lenient treatment by the Belgian criminal justice system reveals its sheer frivolity:

Given that so many Islamist terrorists graduate seamlessly to politico-religious crime from common delinquency, one can say with tolerable certainty that one of the root causes of such terrorism in Europe is liberal penology, with its view that punishment is therapy and prisons are hospitals for the temporarily disturbed or naughty.

Read the piece here

Dalrymple to speak in Australia

The Centre for Independent Studies, an Australian organization that seeks to promote “individual liberty and responsibility, free enterprise, the rule of law and limited, democratic government” will host Dalrymple on a speaking tour of Australia later this month. According to their website, Dalrymple will speak in Brisbane, Sydney and Melbourne in that order. The full schedule and details are here.